City Cast Philly logo

How To Order a Cheesesteak Like a Pro

Posted on September 23, 2024   |   Updated on September 30, 2025

Trenae Nuri

City Cast Philly host Trenae Nuri at Dalessandro’s. (Trenae Nuri/City Cast Philly)

City Cast Philly host Trenae Nuri at Dalessandro’s. (Trenae Nuri/City Cast Philly)

Cheesesteaks are iconic to Philly, but even if you were born and raised here or have lived here for 20 years, you may not know some of the rules for ordering one.

All summer, City Cast Philly’s Trenae Nuri has traveled throughout the city eating cheesesteaks. Just like not all cheesesteaks are made the same, neither are the ways to order them.

Here are things to know so you can order a cheesesteak like a pro.

💰 Bring Cash

Cash is king at some cheesesteak restaurants. Before you stand in line at these spots, make sure you stop by the ATM.

  • Angelo’s
  • Geno’s
  • Jim’s on South Street
  • Dalessandro’s
  • Jim’s West
  • Max's
  • Chubby’s does take cards, but there’s an extra charge for using one.
A cheesesteak from Angelo’s. (Trenae Nuri/City Cast Philly)

A cheesesteak from Angelo’s. (Trenae Nuri/City Cast Philly)

🤔 Know Your Order

Cheesesteak restaurants can get super busy. Check their menu before you get in line. Know exactly what you want on your sandwich, including the kind of cheese, condiments like salt, pepper and/or ketchup, and toppings like hot peppers or pickles.

  • Pro-tip: Jim’s West charges extra for toppings on the side, so just ask for them on your cheesesteak.

🪑Where To Sit

The best time to eat your cheesesteak is right away, while it’s nice and hot. Yet, some cheesesteak restaurants don’t have places where you can sit down and eat your sandwich. So, you may have to sit in your car — but never sit on someone else’s stoop.

These places have seating options:

  • Pat’s King of Steaks (outdoor seating)
  • Geno’s (outdoor seating)
  • John’s Roast Pork (outdoor seating)
  • Philips (outdoor seating)
  • Jim’s on South Street (indoor seating)
  • Dalessandro’s (outdoor seating)
  • Chubby’s (outdoor seating and bar inside)

Share article

Hey Philly

Stay connected to City Cast Philly and get ready to join the local conversation.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.

The latest in Philly

Local CivicsMay 13

What To Know Before You Head to the Polls on May 19

On this month’s ballot are a competitive congressional race and a stacked committee race you may not have known was happening.

Paper cutouts of Democrat and Republic party symbols
Food & DrinkMay 12

Celebrate World Cocktail Day at These Philly Bars

Take a sip of classic and creative cocktails from Philly’s best mixologists.

A selection of cocktails on a bar
Philly's BestMay 11

Where To Golf in Philly

Whether you’re an amateur or a pro, test out your skills at these local golf ranges and courses.

A golfer prepares to hit a golf club
Philly, ExplainedMay 8

Prove Your Weekly Philly Knowledge

Pop quiz, Philly! It’s that time again to test your knowledge on local trivia.

Heart-shaped balloons that say "Happy Mother's Day"
Philly HistoryMay 7

How Philly’s Fairmount Park Came To Be

Starting with just a large hill that left William Penn in awe, Fairmount Park is now the largest landscaped urban park in the world.

Archival photo of Boathouse Row and Fairmount Water Works along the Schuylkill River
Local CivicsMay 6

Council Member on School Closures: ‘Probably the Worst Decision I’ve Seen as an Elected Official’

Councilmember Thomas said the logic behind the closures in the facilities master plan doesn’t match the accomplishments of the schools se...

Portrait photo of Councilmember Isaiah Thomas
Philly, ExplainedMay 5

Which Philly Neighborhoods Suffer From a Sidewalk Gap?

A tool from the Delaware Valley Regional Planning Commission can help you track gaps in the Philly area’s sidewalk network.

Map of the Philadelphia region highlighting sidewalk gaps in yellow, red, and green
Philly, ExplainedMay 4

Philadelphia School Board President on Closures: ‘This Decision Wasn’t Taken Lightly’

Reginald Streater described the situation as ‘disheartening’ and said the board tried everything in its power before it reached such a po...

Headshot of Reginald Streater smiling to the camera